Mental Illness Not really a Driving Pressure Behind Crime

 

Top ten myths about mental illness: 2009 lecture by Joseph Rochford, Ph.D.

Video taken from the channel: CIUSSS de l’Ouest de l’Île de Montréal


 

Allen J. Frances on the overdiagnosis of mental illness

Video taken from the channel: TVO Docs


 

Can a mental illness make someone violent?

Video taken from the channel: CBS News


 

Understanding the Link between Violence and Mental Health | UPMC

Video taken from the channel: UPMC


 

When Mental Illness Leads to Crime: Stigma and Recovery for the Forensic Client

Video taken from the channel: Royal Talks


 

A Different Kind of Force—Policing Mental Illness | NBC Left Field

Video taken from the channel: NBC Left Field


 

I have a mental illness, let me die BBC Stories

Video taken from the channel: BBC Stories


“The vast majority of people with mental illness are not violent, not criminal and not dangerous.” In the study, the researchers analyzed 429 crimes committed by. “The vast majority of people with mental illness are not violent, not criminal and not dangerous.” In the study, the researchers analyzed 429 crimes committed by 143 people in Minnesota who suffered from depression, schizophrenia or bipolar disorder. “The vast majority of people with mental illness are not violent, not criminal and not dangerous.” In the study, the researchers analyzed 429 crimes committed by 143 people in Minnesota who suffered from depression, schizophrenia or bipolar disorder. Growing exposure to racist rhetoric and radical ideology, not mental illness, is driving force behind extreme violence. Cynthia Miller-Idriss is professor of education and sociology at American University, where she directs the Polarization and Extremism Research and Innovation Lab (PERIL).

“It’s really a humanitarian crisis that if you suffer from a severe mental illness in this country, you almost need to commit a crime in order to get into the system.” Almost one-third of people. Mental Health Issues as a Driving Force of Crime We’ve known since a 2006 self-report study that more than half of all prison and jail inmates have mental health problems. These estimates represented 56% of state prisoners, 45% of federal prisoners, and 64% of jail inmates. And yet that’s been the message to alcohol and drug addicts. [ STUDY: Mental Illness Not a Driving Force Behind Crime] The law makes mental and behavioral health treatment.

Often after such brutal acts with no clear motive or explanation, the notion of mental illness appears and should an offender have any history of mental ill health, this becomes their driving force. In 2013 The Sunday Mirror splashed “THREE people are killed by mentally ill. As the mental health system continues to refuse to treat the most seriously ill, they become a police responsibility. they could not force him into treatment because he had not committed a crime. Express-Times, 2/22/13.

New York Magazine has credited him with being the driving force behind the passage of New York’s Kendra’s Law and. The truth is that people who suffer from mental illness are not violent, they are not crazy, they are simply human and misunderstood. Ironic to the stigma that follows them, By Reason of Insanity reports that people who suffer from mental illness are actually 2.5 times more likely to be a victim of a crime.

List of related literature:

Most people with a mental illness, including those with major illnesses, do not commit crimes; but people with mental illness nevertheless are over-represented in the criminal justice system.19 Treatment of mentally ill offenders in Australia is normally served by state and federal legislation.

“Emergency and Trauma Care for Nurses and Paramedics” by Kate Curtis, Clair Ramsden
from Emergency and Trauma Care for Nurses and Paramedics
by Kate Curtis, Clair Ramsden
Elsevier Health Sciences, 2011

Law enforcement officers, prosecutors, defenders, and judges — people on the front lines every day — believe too many people with mental illness become involved in the criminal justice system because the mental health system has somehow failed.

“Ill-equipped: U.S. Prisons and Offenders with Mental Illness” by Sasha Abramsky, Jamie Fellner, Human Rights Watch (Organization)
from Ill-equipped: U.S. Prisons and Offenders with Mental Illness
by Sasha Abramsky, Jamie Fellner, Human Rights Watch (Organization)
Human Rights Watch, 2003

The U.S. is now treating individuals who most require mental health care as criminals; the approach to the criminalization of mental illness is not that different from the approach taken in the 1800s, when the mentally ill were imprisoned rather than treated.

“Handbook on Crime and Deviance” by Marvin D. Krohn, Nicole Hendrix, Gina Penly Hall, Alan J. Lizotte
from Handbook on Crime and Deviance
by Marvin D. Krohn, Nicole Hendrix, et. al.
Springer International Publishing, 2019

Persons who are mentally ill account for a significant number of the calls for police service, although it has been pointed out that “mental illness is not, in and of itself, a police problem.

“Policing in America” by Larry K. Gaines, Victor E. Kappeler
from Policing in America
by Larry K. Gaines, Victor E. Kappeler
Elsevier Science, 2011

Nevertheless, policy in mental health as well as crime is ‘permeated by perceptions and attributions of risk’: mentally disordered offenders who also fall into the current constructions of ‘dangerous for sentencing purposes’ are then particularly likely to be perceived as ‘an unquantifiable danger’ (Peay 2002: 747).

“Sentencing and Punishment: The Quest for Justice” by Susan Easton, Christine Piper
from Sentencing and Punishment: The Quest for Justice
by Susan Easton, Christine Piper
Oxford University Press, 2016

People diagnosed as mentally ill are also protected under the federal laws.

“Guide to Passing the PSI Real Estate Exam” by Lawrence Sager, Joyce Bea Sterling
from Guide to Passing the PSI Real Estate Exam
by Lawrence Sager, Joyce Bea Sterling
Real Estate Education Company, 2000

Nonetheless, the existence of an association between serious mental illness and crime contributes to the stigma experienced by the mentally ill (Volavka & Citrome 2008).

“Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing in the UK, E-Book” by Katie Evans, Debra Nizette, Anthony O'Brien, Catherine Johnson
from Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing in the UK, E-Book
by Katie Evans, Debra Nizette, et. al.
Elsevier Health Sciences, 2019

The problem with mental illness is that so many who have it—especially those in a position to change public attitudes, such as doctors, lawyers, politicians, and military officers—are reluctant to risk talking about mental illness, or seeking help for it.

“Cognitive Errors and Diagnostic Mistakes: A Case-Based Guide to Critical Thinking in Medicine” by Jonathan Howard
from Cognitive Errors and Diagnostic Mistakes: A Case-Based Guide to Critical Thinking in Medicine
by Jonathan Howard
Springer International Publishing, 2018

In the United Kingdom and Europe, the underlying principle is that mental illness per se is an exculpatory factor in offending, and on a pragmatic level, it is accepted that mentally ill offenders are better dealt with by the healthcare system than the penal system.

“Stalking, Threatening, and Attacking Public Figures: A Psychological and Behavioral Analysis” by J. Reid Meloy, Lorraine Sheridan, Jens Hoffmann
from Stalking, Threatening, and Attacking Public Figures: A Psychological and Behavioral Analysis
by J. Reid Meloy, Lorraine Sheridan, Jens Hoffmann
Oxford University Press, 2008

The state has a legitimate interest under its parens patriae powers in providing care to its citizens who are unable because of emotional disorders to care for themselves; the state also has authority under its police power to protect the community from the dangerous tendencies of some who are mentally ill.

“Health Care Law and Ethics” by Mark A. Hall, David Orentlicher, Mary Anne Bobinski, Nicholas Bagley, I. Glenn Cohen
from Health Care Law and Ethics
by Mark A. Hall, David Orentlicher, et. al.
Wolters Kluwer, 2018

Oktay Kutluk

Kutluk Oktay, MD, FACOG is one of the world's foremost experts in fertility preservation as well as ovarian stimulation and in vitro fertilization for infertility treatments. He developed and performed the world's first ovarian transplantation procedures as well as pioneered new ovarian stimulation protocols for embryo and oocyte freezing for breast and endometrial cancer patients.

Mail: [email protected]
Telephone: +1 (877) 492-3666

Biography: https://medicine.yale.edu/profile/kutluk_oktay/
Bibliography: oktay_bibliography

View all posts

19 comments

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • I’m Bi-Polar and Even I Know Don’t Call The Police.
    95% of cops Don’t Know How To Deal With Mental Health Issues.
    A Good Tip: Pickles Help Lower Anxiety.

  • SS facist Victorian police have run them over and stomp them in the head, and victim ends up in coma, if you dont submit you deal with inhuman brutality, in the name of ideology and dictatorship.

  • I found it hard breaking that that lady was trying to comfort those kids and tell them it is her job to prepare them for the outside world… while they sat there and cried and tried to understand the injustice that was made.

  • Psychiatry is the industry of death ��
    As long as there’s a prophet there’s mental illness. Psychiatrists are only interested in money and should be held accountable for their criminal behavior.
    Hopefully history will look back on psychiatry as barbaric.
    Modular medicine is also to blame. Talk about BS, one size fits all mindset. It worked for them it will work for you.
    It’s all about ������������������������������������������

  • Hereby Requesting SUPPORT, Compensation, and Legal Assistance for Citizens and their CHILDREN who were KILLED by “ILLEGAL” Undocumented Immigrants in America for YEARS. See “IN-Complete KNOWN” Victims at: http://www.ojjpac.org/memorial.asp and there are THOUSANDS of VICTIMS Not even Mentioned in this List.
    Citizens Kate Steinle, G.R., Jamiel Shaw and Bologna Children, J.W., Sheriff D. Oliver, Det. M. Davis, Josh Wilkerson, Mendoza, Baby Reedy, And THOUSANDS of VICTIMS were KILLED by ILLEGAL Undocumented immigrants for YEARS Before Donald Trump Ever thought of Running for President, and Many of the KILLINGS Should Have NEVER HAPPEN. Many of the MURDERS Could have been PREVENTED if America Protected its Borders and STOPPED Illegal Immigrants.

    Dennielle Schermock, Sergeant Corey Wride, Dominic Durden, Jose C., Lauren Bump, Anna Dieter-Eckert, Heather M. Coble, Serenity Reedy, Dwayne Polk, Blake Cohorn, Jasmine Yvonne O., Dimitri Smith (Infant), Drew R., V. Pham, Terrell Horne III, Clarisse Grime, Jacqueline Walsh, Sara E., Olivia Monet Wilson, Jerry Laury, Kathleen Byham, Daniel Pollack, Modena L. Dollison, Christopher Rowe, Matthew J. Denice, Corrie A. Damske, Diane K. Bronson, Anna N. Bronson, Jonathan Campbell, Brian A. Terry, Leah Miller, Chance Zobel, Chere C. Osmanhodzic, Matt Landry, Montez Baily, Darness Brown, Shane F., Officer Henry C., Breanna Schneller, Josie Bluhm, Marten Kudlis, Luis A., Mark W. Batin, Brian Tephford, Ellie Bryant and Grayson Hacking were killed by ILLEGAL Immigrants, among Thousands of others.

    Please Support: OJJPAC, ALIPAC, FAIR

    Thank GOD for President Trump after ALL these YEARS!

    References:

    2
    “By the end of the 2014 fiscal year, about 60,000 migrant children will have crossed the U.S. borders without parents, guardians, or papers.”
    (About 60,000 Migrant Children Will Cross The Border Alone This Year, Esther Yu His Lee Feb 28, 2014)

    3
    “70,000 Kids Will Show Up Alone at Our Border This Year. What Happens to Them. Officials have been stunned by a “surge” of unaccompanied children crossing into the United States.” (Ian Gordon July, August 2014 Issue)

    4
    “There are over Four Million Unemployed Americans in the Same Age Group, as those that are DACA Recipients, That Over 950,000 of those are African Americans in the same age group, Over 870,000 Unemployed Hispanics in the same age group. Those are large Groups of people that are Unemployed that could possibly have those jobs.” (Sarah Huckabee Sanders, White House Press Briefing September 5, 2017)

    5
    IRS Found 1.2 Million Cases of Identity Theft by Illegal Immigrants (By Theodore Bunker, Friday, 16 Mar 2018 )
    https://www.newsmax.com/newsfront/irs-illegal-immigrants-identity-theft-fraud/2018/03/16/id/849101/?ns_mail_uid=106533350&ns_mail_job=1784225_03162018&s=al&dkt_nbr=010102wzwgp8

    6
    Black Jobseekers File Discrimination Suit Against Staffing Agency That Favored Hispanics (By Nigel Roberts, December 7, 2016) https://newsone.com/3609866/black-jobseekers-file-federal-discrimination-suit-against-chicago-mvp-staffing-agency/

    7
    Black Workers’ Suit Accuses Job Agency of Favoring Hispanic Applicants, By LIAM STACK, DEC. 6, 2016 https://www.nytimes.com/2016/12/06/us/lawsuit-alleges-discrimination-against-blacks-at-national-job-agency.html?_r=0
    (God Only Knows how many Citizens are Incarcerated because of Lack of Work, and Possibly because of JOBS Taken Away from Citizens because of DACA, and Illegal Immigrants!

    8
    Newark Triple Murder Fuels Debate on Treatment of Illegal Immigrants (By KAREEM FAHIM, AUG. 19, 2007)
    https://www.nytimes.com/2007/08/19/nyregion/19newark.html
    (Murder victims Terrance Aeriel, Iofemi Hightower and Dashon Harvey, three teens murdered on August 4, 2007. Crime in Newark, NJ)

    9
    Man in U.S. illegally is convicted of killing 2 deputies, tells court: ‘I’m going to kill more cops soon’ (By Associated Press, Feb 09, 2018) Retrieved from:
    http://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-deputy-killing-20180209-story.html

    10
    “According to DHS status indicators, over 258,000 criminal aliens have been booked into local Texas jails between June 1, 2011 and June 30, 2018, of which over 173,000 were classified as illegal aliens by DHS.
    Between June 1, 2011 and June 30, 2018, these 173,000 illegal aliens were charged with more than 269,000 criminal offenses..” (Texas Department of Public Safety, Texas Criminal Illegal Alien Data, access 7-21-2018)
    https://www.dps.texas.gov/administration/crime_records/pages/txCriminalAlienStatistics.htm

    11
    “An immigrant who had been brought to the United States illegally as a 10-year-old was convicted of tying up her son and torturing him before beating him to death, because he accused Josh of “kicking his dog,” (Ms. Wilkerson, NYT, Jul.21, 2015)
    https://www.nytimes.com/politics/first-draft/2015/07/21/donald-trump-is-thanked-by-woman-whose-son-was-killed-by-illegal-immigrant/

    12
    “We are being invaded, and the quicker the politicians realize it is an invasion, the quicker they will close the border,” said Mr. Lorenzo Anzaldua. “Landowners like Lorenzo Anzaldua have seen their property turned into a virtual highway for scores of women and children desperately racing across the border.” Anna Werner reports. (CBS Evening News, Published on Jul 21, 2014, Anna Werner reports)

    13
    “The hearing, in Mcallen, Texas, is called “Crisis on the Texas Border: Surge of Unaccompanied Minors…”
    “More than 52,000 children have been picked up along the southern border; most without their parents and most from Guatemala, El Salvador and Honduras.”
    (By Katie Marzullo, ABC7 News, July 03, 2014)
    https://abc7news.com/news/east-bay-congressman-sits-in-on-immigration-hearing/153897/

    14
    Mark Kilroy, a med student, was murdered at Texas-Mexico border by evil worshippers in Mexico. 11 other bodies found. (By Renee Haines. UPI Archives, April 13, 1989)

    15
    39 MILLION: IRLI Investigation Reveals Massive Identity Fraud by Illegal Aliens)
    WASHINGTON—In pursuit of its mission to safeguard American citizens from the harmful effects of mass migration, the Immigration Reform Law Institute (IRLI) has found that 39 million Americans have potentially had their Social Security numbers stolen by illegal aliens pursuing work in the country during the Obama administration (IRLI, 9-11-2018)
    http://www.irli.org/single-post/2018/09/11/39-MILLION-IRLI-Investigation-Reveals-Massive-Identity-Fraud-by-Illegal-Aliens

    16)
    Luis Rodrigo Perez, 23, a Mexican national, is accused of killing three people in Missouri, authorities say. (Associated Press)
    An illegal immigrant accused of a triple murder in Missouri was previously jailed and released in New Jersey on domestic violence charges, authorities said, putting the spotlight on the conflict between local and immigration authorities nationwide.
    Luis Rodrigo Perez, 23, a native of Mexico, is charged with fatally shooting two men and wounding two others on Nov. 1 and fatally shooting a woman the next day.
    (By Louis Casiano, Fox News. Illegal immigrant killed 3 after ‘sanctuary’ release from custody, ICE says)
    https://www.foxnews.com/us/undocumented-immigrant-released-from-jail-charged-in-triple-murder

    17, “A large group of illegal immigrants is observed moving to the U.S. border near Yuma, Arizona where they crossed into the country illegally before being apprehended. (U.S. Customs and Border Protection)
    As thousands of troops deployed to the southern border await the arrival of a caravan of migrants heading towards the U.S., border patrol agents in Arizona have already been busy, detaining more than 650 illegal immigrants in just two days this week.
    Agents in the Yuma Sector said they detained 654 people – most reportedly being family units or unaccompanied minors from Guatemala on Monday and Tuesday.
    A total of 521,090 people were apprehended at the southern border in fiscal year 2018 – up 125 percent from 451,514 in fiscal year 2017. Just in Yuma, more than 26,000 people were apprehended in fiscal year 2018.”
    “More than 650 illegal immigrants crossing southern border detained in Arizona over two days” (11-15-2018 By Lucia I. Suarez Sang, Fox News)
    https://www.foxnews.com/us/more-than-650-illegal-immigrants-crossing-southern-border-detained-in-arizona-over-two-days

    18, “Newly released dashcam video shows the moments a police officer in Arkansas stared down the barrel of a gun during an intense shootout with an illegal immigrant suspect over the weekend.Luis Cobos-Cenobio has been charged with four counts of attempted capital murder, committing a terroristic act, fleeing, possession of a controlled substance and possession of drug paraphernalia, according to police.”
    (Dashcam video shows moment illegal immigrant suspect opens fire on Arkansas police officer. By Travis Fedschun, Fox News. 11-15-2018)

  • I just got baker acted 2 weeks ago I blacked out I just feel lucky I got beaten up and not shot…I got to wake up the next day…RIP to all that have suffered and been killed by police or anyone that may not understand

  • Right off the bat he states vaccinations are not a cause for MH disorders. Wrong. Drugs however are not the answer yet Shrinks prescribe them to children. Whatever.

  • The fact that a mom has to tell her kids that they might get shot just because they are black is absolutely disturbing.

    And if someone has mental breakdown, why call the police? I’d call a doctor or something.

  • What gets me is that this kid went to school with other kids. In adult life, an employer doesn’t put up with behavior issues at work, as it’s a waste of time and money, plus brings down morale. But in the public schools, these kids are difficult to place, so many never make it to Special Education. Also, we have inclusive classrooms nowadays, therefore kids with behavior disorders are intentionally kept in regular education classrooms. So sweet innocent classmates deal with this early in life!

  • Watch this carefully. If the wrong officers came to these situations. More people wouldnt be here. The calm you see after the panic wouldn’t exists. Some people are victims of themselves. We need all officers trained for this. And the ones that crack under pressure should be removed from the force as unfit. Just like anyone else that can’t live up to the expectations of there jobs. A small change would make a huge difference. These people don’t choose to be I’ll. Most dont really want to die. The sadness, shame, and failure is unspeakable. Pray for change and understanding. After the rage. Theres mostly pain and confusion. Death is something that can’t be fixed or revirsed. Its a last resort not a reaction.

  • Manipulation, power, and access to money and resources are some of the amplifying causes of the behavioral problems and the increasing epidemic statistics (Species by definition share characteristics essential to the group).
    And the placebo effect is in some way related to that because it deals with reaffirmation and needs of the person and the group,  So in a way the social manipulators and egotistic persons, that are affecting society, are being subject to the same placebo effect, but the difference is in the lack of empathy and realization of consequences, due to ‘power’ and ‘authority’ as their primary need.

    That is linked by the major need of money that in the current society, with all kinds of rules/laws shaping it, drives and projects further development.

    Just ask yourself what happens if you diminish the use of money for every day activities but still get half of things done? money and businesses, and their associated power, are negatively affected.

    Why are the good contributions attached to money production only? why are the wrong people rewarded in spite of the obvious detrimental risk attached to their behavior?

    Because of social conditioning is the normalizing factor, and is wrongly perceived or called ‘culture’, Once people figure that out, like the placebo effect, it yields a better diagnostic and points to the therapy.

  • Glad to see this Francis guy has a conscience. It seems so few psychiatrists do. They just keep their blinders on and assume everything they do is helping people because the drugs’ efficacy was established in a clinical trial and approved by the FDA.

  • Allen J. Frances Needs to take Major Tranquilisers
    That is the only way he will ever learn that they shouldn’t be used on Humans or Animals
    I said for over 20 years that I would never want my worst enemy to take Major Tranquilisers
    Because even VERY SHORT TERM USE of these poisons can screw your
    Brain, Body and Nervous System up for life
    If people like Allen J. Frances were to screw up their own Bodies, Brains and Nervous Systems
    They would then at least learn what sort of HELP we Patients and Ex Patients really need
    To still have a good life.

  • dear allen, also psychiatrists give you medication in 10 minutes. so where is the big difference between them and normal doctor? so the problem also lies by psychiatry. 😉

  • This is one of the dumbest morons in University psychiatrists and CNN loves him but most of the people at CNN are or should be in psychiatrist wards.

  • As long as leaders force police to deal with violent delusional manic mentally ill people instead of forcing them in mental institutions then cops shouldnt be responsible if they feared for their life. They are not trained mental professionals. If mentally ill dont want to stay in hospital even if they are delusional and manic, they are free to leave. My brother did and assaulted hospitalized a man, stole money, damaged two vehicles, and coincidently burned residence down, and arrested all within 2 days of being released from hospital.

  • Why are untrained people with guns allowed to approach the mentally ill at all when they aren’t doing anything criminal? How many police officers are mentally ill as a result of just doing their job? What we have is a failure to bring the people who need help to the people who can actually help them and vice-versa.

  • as someone who has been taken in by the police when mentally unwell, this isn’t how they should have handled it.:(

    the high five, the ‘just relax’ should have been ‘it’s going to be okay, we are here for you, we got you bro’ as ‘just relax’ makes it feel like we are over-reacting, are being silly/childish and we will fight back or hide for feeling like we are not being believed. then ‘there’s no point in fighting this’, ugh. no! ‘tonight, this is what’s going to happen and then in the morning we could review this.’ language is everything!!!

  • A lot of people are saying what they should and should not say, what they should or should not do but these people do not have mental illness they don’t know what the Mentally Ill are going through, they’re trying their best to help you not hurt yourself and give them some credit for trying when no one else is trying to do this. There is level of understanding that needs to be had on both sides of the field and this may not be possible. Nobody wants mental illness but unfortunately we live in a broken world. So instead of shooting them down in these comments for incompetency how about saying something they should know, as in you should say this instead of this and know that it will differ in every situation.